AceShowbiz - NSYNC spilled old secrets when playing "Never Have I Ever" on "The Ellen DeGeneres Show", but one fact leaves a lingering question. When Ellen DeGeneres asked Justin Timberlake, JC Chasez, Chris Kirkpatrick, Joey Fatone and Lance Bass if they have ever hooked up with a Spice Girl, everybody was quick to lift up their "I Have Never" paddles, except for Justin who hesitantly showed his paddle.
The 37-year-old singer eventually turned his paddle around to show the words "I Have", but he wouldn't say which of the Spice Girls members he once hooked up with. Of course, fans wouldn't let it go away, as they have been coming up with guesses about which Spice Girl it was.
Interestingly, Emma Bunton once got coy when asked if she and Justin ever had a tryst. In an episode of "The Jonathan Ross Show" from 2004, the Baby Spice was asked by host Jonathan Ross, "You had a one nighter with him, is that right?"
A blushed Emma scolded him, "Jonathan!" But Jonathan continued to press her, "I heard this to be true!" Emma couldn't give a direct answer and said, "We hung out and partied a bit and he was very sweet. He spoke about this first, 'cause otherwise I would not have said a word. He's very sweet."
Additionally, during her appearance on "This Morning" in 2003, the 42-year-old British star refused to comment when asked if she was secretly dating Justin. "I can't say," she said.
Back to NSYNC's appearance on "The Ellen DeGeneres Show", the boys were also asked if they ever hooked up with someone twice their age, to which Chris and Joey admitted they had. Joey, Chris and Justin raised their "I Have" paddles when asked if they ever hooked up with someone that another band member dated.
Meanwhile, all of them confessed that they have ever hooked up on a tour bus and forgotten the song lyrics on stage. As for the question "Never have I ever hooked up to an NSYNC song," they all said no.